Navigating Change in a Shifting Landscape
In the wild world of real estate, the market sometimes feels like a snow globe—just when you think things have settled, someone gives it a good shake. This November, the housing economy is anything but calm. Mortgage rates are playing an unpredictable game of limbo, builders are cautiously optimistic yet slowing down, and inventory shortages are keeping buyers on edge.
For appraisers, the challenge isn’t just interpreting the numbers—it’s navigating the emotions, expectations, and economic ripples that come with them.
Stay on top of your career and the appraisal industry—take a look at our wide selection of appraisal continuing education courses!
If the housing market were a soap opera, the Fed’s rate cuts would be the season’s biggest plot twist. This November, the Federal Reserve continued its easing cycle with a 25-basis-point rate cut, bringing the Federal Funds Rate to 4.5%-4.75% (realtor.com). While buyers and sellers hoped this move would send mortgage rates tumbling, the reality has been more complex. Long-term rates like mortgages don’t always follow the Fed’s lead, and this time is no exception.
Meanwhile, the housing market continues to wrestle with tight inventory, affordability challenges, and unpredictable buyer behavior. For appraisers, it’s a time to stay sharp, adapt to rapid changes, and understand the broader economic forces at play.
Whether it’s assessing values for cautious buyers or determining the impact of inventory constraints, this is the moment to connect the dots—and maybe have a little fun while you’re at it. Let’s dive in!
1. Mortgage Rates: The Drama Continues
The roller-coaster ride of mortgage rates shows no signs of slowing. After briefly hitting two-year lows in September, rates shot back up to over 6.7% in October, driven by rising bond yields and lingering inflation concerns (Freddie Mac).
Despite the Federal Reserve cutting rates by 25 basis points in November, mortgage rates remain stubbornly high due to long-term economic factors. Historically, Fed rate cuts don’t always translate into immediate mortgage rate relief—and this cycle appears to be no exception.
The Federal Reserve’s December meeting looms large, with the potential for another rate cut if inflation continues to cool. However, any significant easing in mortgage rates likely won’t arrive until 2025 (Freddie Mac).
Appraisers, take note: With buyers hesitant to lock in loans at these rates, the volume of purchase-related appraisals may remain subdued for now. That said, be prepared for a potential rise in refinance appraisals as rates inch downward.
2. Existing Home Sales: A Flicker of Life
In a surprising twist, existing home sales rebounded in October, rising 3.4% from the previous month and marking the first year-over-year gain in more than three years (realtor.com). This uptick is largely attributed to contracts signed during September’s lower rate environment. However, with mortgage rates climbing again, the sustainability of this trend remains uncertain.
Regional nuances are key: Sales are gaining momentum in regions like the Midwest and Northeast, where prices have appreciated at a more moderate pace compared to the South and West (Freddie Mac).
For appraisers: This recovery in existing home sales is a reminder to stay attuned to regional dynamics. Property valuations will vary widely based on local inventory, demand, and affordability.
3. New Home Sales and Construction: Slowing Down But Not Out
Newly built home sales fell sharply in October, down 17.3% month-over-month, as affordability challenges and competition from existing homes took their toll). Builders, meanwhile, are slowing their pace. Single-family housing starts dropped nearly 7%, reflecting cautious optimism tempered by elevated costs and labor shortages.
Yet, builder confidence is ticking upward, buoyed by expectations of regulatory relief and potential rate declines in 2025 (National Association of Home Builders). The new-home market remains a bright spot for buyers seeking turnkey options with modern amenities.
What this means for appraisers: While new construction activity is slowing, inventory levels are growing. Keep an eye on the increasing number of completed homes hitting the market, as they may create more opportunities for appraisals.
4. The Housing Shortage: A Persistent Challenge
The U.S. housing market continues to struggle with a shortfall of 3.7 million units (Freddie Mac). Despite years of construction gains, demand continues to outpace supply, especially in the single-family segment. The result? Higher prices, tighter competition, and affordability pressures that show no signs of easing.
Multifamily construction projects are adding much-needed rental units to the market, but single-family home inventory remains critically constrained. For first-time buyers, the situation is particularly grim, with affordability challenges pushing homeownership further out of reach.
Appraisers should watch: Tight supply in high-demand markets is likely to keep upward pressure on prices. Understanding how these dynamics play out locally will be key to accurate valuations.
5. Looking Ahead: The Fed’s Next Moves
The Federal Reserve’s policy decisions in December could set the tone for the housing market heading into 2025. If inflation data remains stable, another rate cut could provide much-needed relief to mortgage rates. However, economic surprises—such as stronger-than-expected job growth or stubborn inflation—could lead to a pause in rate cuts, prolonging the high-rate environment (realtor.com).
For appraisers, the takeaway is clear: Stay nimble. Economic conditions are in flux, and understanding the broader financial landscape will help you anticipate shifts in demand for your services, whether for purchases, refinances, or market adjustments.
Final Thoughts: Appraising in an Ever-Changing Market
November has shown us that the housing market is as complex and unpredictable as ever. For appraisers, the challenge lies not just in interpreting market data but in connecting it to the real-world decisions of buyers, sellers, and lenders. Whether it’s navigating the impact of rising rates, adjusting to regional variations in sales activity, or understanding the nuances of housing supply shortages, your role as an appraiser has never been more critical.
So, take a deep breath, sharpen your tools, and keep an eye on the horizon. As we head into 2025, one thing is certain: The housing market will keep us on our toes. But hey, if it were easy, everyone would do it—and what’s life without a little challenge? Here’s to staying steady in the face of change!
