When it comes to appraising waterfront properties, you’re not just valuing a piece of land—you’re capturing a lifestyle, a view, and sometimes, a dream. But, with the beauty of water, comes a wave of unique factors that set these properties apart from their inland neighbors.
From the ripple effect of water views to the impact of seasonal boat traffic, understanding these nuances can make all the difference. In this blog, we’ll cover some key elements that can make or break the value of waterfront properties to help you navigate these waters with confidence.
Want to learn more about appraising complex properties? Sign up for this continuing education course.
1. Water Frontage and Access
One of the most critical elements in appraising waterfront properties is the type and extent of water frontage. The value can vary significantly depending on whether the property is adjacent to a lake, river, ocean, or pond.
The length of the property’s water shoreline can greatly impact its value. More water frontage typically means higher value, as it provides more access to water-based activities and enhances the aesthetic appeal and privacy from neighboring properties. Buyers may desire a certain amount of water frontage, but beyond a certain point, additional frontage might not add significant value.
For example, having 200 feet of frontage may be highly desirable, but increasing that to 400 feet might not double the property’s value, as the utility and appeal of the additional frontage could be marginal.
Determine whether the water access is seasonal (e.g., water levels fluctuate or freeze in winter) or permanent. Year-round access often increases the property’s appeal and value.
Evaluating the Type of Water Access and Shore
The nature of the shoreline—whether rocky, sandy, or marshy—also plays a role in valuation. For instance, a sandy beach is usually more desirable than a rocky shore, depending on the intended use and views.
Unlike a sandy beach, which invites sunbathing, swimming, and easy access to the water, a marshy area can be muddy, difficult to navigate, and may harbor insects like mosquitoes. The dense vegetation and soggy ground can make it challenging to enjoy the water or set up outdoor spaces like docks or patios. Additionally, marshy areas might emit odors during certain times of the year, further diminishing their desirability.
As a result, properties with marshy access often have lower market appeal and can impact the overall valuation compared to properties with more user-friendly shorelines.
While properties located on islands may have unique appeal due to their exclusivity, they might also face access challenges and higher maintenance costs, which should be considered.
When I first appraised waterfront properties, I worked with a subject matter expert (SME) who shared how the bodies of water along the chain of lakes in my area were not all identical. The differences were significant, affecting value and appeal.
For instance, being on the northern bay side of the main lake offered calm, scenic views, whereas homes on the southern lake were plagued by high boat traffic during the summer, making it noisy and less desirable.
2. Topography and Exposure
The topography of a waterfront property—its elevation and slope—can influence not only the view but also the utility of the land and its susceptibility to flooding. Additionally, a property’s predominant exposure (e.g., north-facing vs. south) can affect its natural light, wind protection, and heating/cooling needs, all of which are important considerations.
3. Local Zoning and Environmental Regulations
Waterfront properties are often subject to stricter zoning laws and environmental regulations, which can dictate how close structures can be built to the water, the types of structures allowed (e.g., docks, boathouses), and even the types of recreational activities permitted (i.e. boats with or without motors). Non-compliance can lead to costly penalties, so understanding local zoning is crucial.
Additionally, environmental regulations may limit tree removal, landscaping changes, and septic system placement to protect the water body’s ecosystem. These restrictions can impact the property’s development potential and, consequently, its value.
4. Water Quality and Levels
The health of the water body is a vital factor as poor water quality can deter potential buyers and lower property value. It can also affect recreational activities and wildlife. You should inquire about any pollution issues or environmental reports.
Seasonal fluctuations or regulated water levels can influence property usability. For example, if water levels drop significantly, a dock may become unusable or the property may be prone to flooding during seasonal high water levels.
5. Depth of the Water
The depth of a water body significantly affects its usability, particularly for recreational activities like boating, fishing, and swimming. Shallow water might limit boating and can lead to stagnant water, which may contribute to unpleasant odors and an increase in insects like mosquitoes.
Conversely, deeper water is often clearer, supports a healthier ecosystem, and is more desirable for recreational use, thereby enhancing property value.
6. Utilities and Services
Properties may rely on well water or other sources that need evaluation for quality and reliability. Additionally, heating types (e.g., electric, wood, propane) can vary widely, impacting energy costs and property appeal.
Many waterfront properties use septic systems, which require regular maintenance and must comply with environmental regulations. Understanding the state and capacity of these systems is essential.
Proximity to power lines or the availability of electricity can significantly influence value, particularly in more remote waterfront locations.
7. Type of Shoreline
The type of shoreline impacts both the aesthetic appeal and the stability of the property. Natural, vegetated shorelines often prevent erosion, enhance the visual appeal, and support local wildlife. On the other hand, developed or hardened shorelines may increase erosion downstream or negatively impact the natural beauty of the area.
The stability and type of the shoreline are crucial for long-term property value, as eroding shorelines can lead to land loss, affecting both the usability of the land and the structures on it.
8. Erosion and its Costs
Erosion is a significant concern for properties near water bodies. The costs to repair or mitigate erosion can be astronomical, running into millions of dollars. These costs may include installing seawalls, replenishing beaches, or other engineering solutions to stabilize the shoreline. Such expenses can drastically reduce a property’s value and deter potential buyers.
9. Secondary Structures and Amenities
Secondary structures, such as boathouses, decks, cabins, and docks, can add substantial value to a waterfront property. Consider how these structures enhance the property’s usability and appeal. For example, a well-maintained dock can significantly boost the value for buyers interested in boating.
Available Resources for Assessing Water Bodies
- EPA Reports: The EPA provides comprehensive water quality assessments, setting limits on pollutants and offering data on water health.
- Local Environmental Agencies: These agencies often conduct regular water testing and provide public reports on water quality. Contact your local department of environmental protection for detailed information.
- US Geological Survey (USGS): The USGS offers data on water depth, flow rates, and other hydrological factors that are essential in evaluating a water body’s impact on surrounding properties.
- NOAA Shoreline Website: The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) provides data on shoreline changes and erosion, which are critical for understanding the stability and future risks associated with waterfront properties.
Understanding the Nuances & Preparing for Appraising Waterfront Property
Appraising waterfront properties involves a comprehensive evaluation of various factors that go beyond typical residential appraisals. By considering the unique aspects of water frontage, local regulations, environmental factors, and property-specific amenities, you can provide credible and comprehensive valuations that reflect the worth of these highly sought-after properties.
Understanding the depth, quality of the water, and type of shoreline is crucial, as these elements directly influence the property’s usability, aesthetics, and long-term stability. The importance of these factors cannot be overstated, and they deserve careful consideration in every waterfront property appraisal.
While an entire course could be dedicated to the intricacies of valuing waterfront properties, this blog is intended to highlight some of the more common issues.
Gain More Opportunity with a Luxury Home Appraisal Certification
Luxury homes present a wealth of opportunities to appraisers. Download a free copy of Upgrade Your Career with Luxury Home Appraisals to discover how to make the leap from appraising traditional homes to high-end, luxury homes.
